
Illustration of the dust jacket of an edition of The Sycamore Tree listed for sale online, not my personal copy, which is jacketless, faded and rather tattered.
The Sycamore Tree by Elizabeth Cambridge ~ 1934. This edition: G.P. Putnam’s Sons, 1934. Hardcover. 328 pages.
With this, her second novel, published in 1934, a year after the release of the highly esteemed Hostages to Fortune, Elizabeth Cambridge establishes her place in mid-century literature not so much as a great novelist but as a genuinely good one.
The tale follows, in an economically yet meticulously depicted linear trajectory, the life of Howell Combes, from his childhood as youngest sibling of three in an upper-middle-class naval officer’s family, through his school years and his apprenticeship as an engineer, the dark years of the Great War, an ultimately disastrous marriage to a foster-sister, and the attainment at last of a secret desire, the inheritance of his grandfather’s country estate.
Joanna Cannan in The Bookman, April 1934, reviewed The Sycamore Tree with more-than-restrained enthusiasm; her review identifies both the strengths and weaknesses of this novel.
In her second novel Miss Elizabeth Cambridge has set herself a difficult, interesting task, the task of writing the story of an “average” man. “The Sycamore Tree” is a good book, but I found it, as I found “Hostages to Fortune”, vaguely depressing. Is this all there is to life? can childhood, youth and early manhood pass so soberly? does love come and go with so little agony, so mild a joy? It is all very well to paint, and to paint perfectly, the domestic scene: Howell Combe was a dull, worthy fellow, one of those unfortunate beings whose wants never exceed their means, but he did not miss the deepest experiences that life can offer us, and in those experiences surely there is blood and tears, beauty and joy. This book in short should have been a moving one, but it is not. Nothing is here to “knock the breast”. It is an excellent book, but one reads it without emotion, and it is wrong, I feel, that the record of an “average” life should leave on so utterly unmoved.
Damning with faint praise, indeed!
I agree with Miss Cannan in her assessment of the novel’s strengths, but I differ in that I did find the subfusc saga of Howell moving; his agonies and joys were real enough to this reader. Though I did not find it “knocked the breast”, my own response was certainly much more subdued than dramatic, but it was all so very relatable, so mostly true-to-life in its essence.
Edited on May 28 to add this comment on The Sycamore Tree from Vera Brittain, quoted on the back of the dust jacket of The Two Doctors, Cambridge’s 1936 novel, which I’m currently writing about:
This tale of a naval officer’s son, the youngest in an ordinary middle-class family living at Plymouth before the War, is a perfect thing of its limited kind. It leaves behind it the feeling that life is profound, significant, and infinitely worth while.
Yes, indeed.
A rather good book by a better-than-average writer. Recommended, if you can find it – most Elizabeth Cambridge novels are elusively rare.
My rating: 9/10.
My personal copy has an intriguing extra, a faintly pencilled two-stanza poem written on a blank back page. An original attempt by an earlier owner? I puzzled out most of it, but some of the words are difficult to decipher. I include it for anyone who’d like to work it out themself. I don’t think it is a quotation; it has the amateur’s ring to it.
I rather loved Hostages to Fortune, so would consider this a real find if I happened across it. I so love mysterious inscriptions inside old books, in fact I am always vaguely disappointed when there aren’t any.
If you find *any* Elizabeth Cambridge book, grab it! Other than Hostages to Fortune they are very rare. I am hoping someone (Persephone? Dean Street Press?) will see fit to take a look at these, too, because they are very good novels, beautifully written and valuable records of their time.
And yes – inscriptions are grand, aren’t they? Messages from the past…
i have this one thankfully and its free to read via HATHI TRUST online.
Thrilled to have bought 2 old Margery Sharp books for 80p.One was her rare second book FANFARE FOR TIN TRUMPETS.the tatty copy of FOUR GARDENS was a duplicate and signed by the author.I have photos if you tell me where to send them.
The Margery Sharps – WOW! Great find. Fanfare for Tin Trumpets is possibly even more rare than Rhododendron Pie! And Four Gardens is exceedingly rare as well. I think you can post photos in the comment section here – if you could do that on the posts for those books it would be lovely.
i would rather have the Cambridges books but mustn’t grumble.
cant send photos unless i have your email address.sorry.still trying.
I loved Hostages to Fortune (hard to believe it was her first book) but have never seen anything else by Cambridge in any library or bookstore. I trust you more than I do Joanna Cannan so if I come across this I’ll definitely snap it up.